Best Tires For Model S: Compare EV, All-Season and UHP Options

#1 · Best Overall

1. Sailun ERange EV

• Size: 235/40R19
• Rim Size: 19 in
• Load Capacity: 16 oz
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/40R19

Best for: Electric-vehicle touring comfort.

Why it ranks #1: Its 235/40R19 size may suit some Model S setups, and EV-specific design, reinforced sidewalls, all-season construction and a 45,000-mile limited tread-life warranty are listed.

Sailun’s reinforced sidewall addresses the load demands associated with battery weight while supporting handling and cornering, making the ERange EV specifically relevant to electric and hybrid cars. The 235/40R19 XL size and 45,000-mile limited tread-life claim give Model S shoppers concrete details to compare.

Liquid phase mixing and EcoPoint3 technology are tied to long-lasting tread life and enhanced wet- or dry-road grip, while the reinforced sidewall is intended to increase load-carrying capacity for battery weight and improve handling and cornering. Sailun also identifies this as an all-season EV tire and states a 45,000-mile limited manufacturer tread life. Its 235/40R19 specification is the fit reference; it should not be assumed to suit every Model S.

Skip it if you need an 18-inch tire for a different approved setup; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS is listed in 235/45R18.

Consider this all-season EV tire if the Model S uses the listed 235/40R19 size and you value its reinforced sidewall and stated wet-and-dry grip. Size and vehicle load requirements remain decisive fit considerations.

Listed on Amazon as: Sailun ERange EV Touring 235/40R19 96W XL Electric Vehicle Tire

#2 · Best EV Summer

2. Pirelli P Zero PZ5

• Size: 325/35R22
• Rim Size: 22 in
• Load Capacity: 2 lb
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 325/35R22

Best for: Wide 22-inch performance touring.

Why it ranks #2: Designed for high-performance sedans and EVs, it lists wet- and dry-weather braking benefits; its 325/35R22 size is a key fitment limitation.

Pirelli’s plasticized rubber compound is stated to boost braking and handling in wet and dry weather, giving this 325/35R22 P Zero PZ5 a clear performance focus. The tire is intended for high-performance coupes, sedans, and EVs, while its 22-inch rim specification makes wheel-size matching essential.

Steep, inclined groove angles are intended to improve handling and stability, while the plasticized compound supports braking and handling in both wet and dry weather. Progressive sipes and carefully designed tread blocks lower road noise for a quieter ride, and the optimized tread pattern is linked to longer tread life. Pirelli specifies use when temperatures stay consistently above 45°F, so this is a warm-condition choice rather than a universal seasonal option.

Skip it if you need a listed 18-inch tire or temperatures regularly fall below Pirelli’s stated threshold; Michelin Pilot Sport 4S is a 245/40ZR18 summer option.

Consider it for a compatible 22-inch high-performance EV or sedan setup in consistently warm conditions. Its 325/35R22 dimensions are a substantial fit constraint, so compare them with the exact Model S wheel and tire specification.

Listed on Amazon as: Pirelli P Zero (PZ5) Performance 325/35R22 110Y Passenger Tire

#3 · Best All-Season

3. Hankook Ventus S1 AS

• Size: 235/45R18
• Rim Size: 18 in
• Load Capacity: 16 oz
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/45R18

Best for: Year-round 18-inch driving.

Why it ranks #3: Its 235/45R18 size and all-season compound suit buyers checking an 18-inch setup, with four water-funneling grooves and a reinforced construction.

An all-season rubber compound gives the Hankook Ventus S1 AS stated traction for year-round use, including light winter weather, making it a practical alternative to summer-only tires. Its 235/45R18 size and four wide water-funneling grooves add specific fit and wet-road considerations for a Model S owner.

Hankook’s all-season tread pattern is specified for wet, dry, and light-winter conditions, while four wide grooves funnel water out of the tread to support wet traction. Reinforced construction is linked to strength, load carrying capacity, and longer tread life. An optimized design also lowers road noise and vibration for a quieter ride. Together, these details suit drivers seeking seasonal versatility, though the listed 235/45R18 size still needs to match the vehicle’s approved setup.

Skip it if you need a 20-inch summer tire with wet braking emphasized; the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asym 5 is listed in 255/40R20.

This fits the needs of a driver seeking one all-season tire for wet, dry, and light-winter use, plus stated noise reduction. Check the 235/45R18 size against the exact Model S configuration before selecting it.

Listed on Amazon as: Hankook Ventus S1 AS (H125) UHP 235/45R18 98V XL Passenger Tire

#4 · Best Summer Performance

4. Michelin Pilot Sport 4S

• Size: 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL
• Rim Size: 18 in
• Load Capacity: 1609 lb
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL

Best for: Summer grip and wet braking.

Why it ranks #4: The 245/40ZR18 XL tire lists high-speed handling, dry grip and wet braking strengths, plus a 30,000-mile limited treadwear warranty.

Exceptional dry grip and wet braking are the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S’s clearest draws, enabling a performance-focused summer setup with handling and control even at high speed. This listing is for one 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL tire, so it identifies a single tire rather than a complete set.

Michelin describes the Pilot Sport 4S as derived from the Pilot Super Sport and born from endurance racing, while its stated road benefits are handling and control at high speed, dry grip, and wet braking. Those attributes make it relevant to drivers prioritizing summer performance across changing road conditions. The 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL size and 18-inch rim specification give a concrete comparison point for a Model S’s required tire dimensions; rims are not included.

Skip it if you need an all-season tire for light winter conditions; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS is listed for year-round use.

Choose this single tire when summer dry grip, wet braking, and high-speed control are priorities. It is not a complete replacement set, and its 245/40ZR18 size must match the Model S configuration before ordering.

Listed on Amazon as: Michelin Pilot Sport 4S 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL (Set of 1 Tire Only)

#5

5. Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5

• Size: P255/40R20
• Rim Size: 20 in
• Load Capacity: 16 oz
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 255/40R20

Best for: 20-inch summer comfort.

Why it ranks #5: This 255/40R20 summer performance tire lists wet braking and luxurious comfort, though its seasonal focus may not suit year-round use in colder climates.

Goodyear specifies luxurious comfort alongside wet braking performance for this ultra-high-performance summer tire, making it a 20-inch option for drivers weighing ride quality against performance. The 255/40R20 size and 101W XL marking provide the key specifications to compare with a Model S’s approved tire setup.

The product is identified as a premium ultra-high-performance summer tire, with the supplied description highlighting wet braking and luxurious comfort. That combination makes the stated use case more specific than a general passenger tire, particularly for drivers who want wet-weather stopping performance without overlooking ride comfort. Its 255/40R20 size and 20-inch rim specification establish the wheel dimensions to compare, while the XL marking and 101W designation are part of the listed tire specification.

Skip it if you want listed all-season capability in an 18-inch size; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS specifies year-round traction.

This is a candidate for a Model S owner whose approved setup uses 255/40R20 tires and who values the stated summer performance, wet braking, and comfort combination. The listing does not establish fit across Model S versions.

Listed on Amazon as: Goodyear 255/40R20 101W XL GOODYEAR EAG F1 ASYM 5 SBL T0

#6

6. Lexani LXUHP-207

• Size: 235/45ZR18
• Rim Size: 18 in
• Load Capacity: 1653 lb
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/45R18

Best for: Warm-weather highway performance.

Why it ranks #6: The 235/45ZR18 XL tire offers a 50,000-mile limited tread-life warranty, water-evacuating grooves and a V-shaped pattern for higher-speed traction.

The V-shaped tread pattern targets traction and braking at higher speeds, giving performance-oriented drivers a specific reason to consider the Lexani LXUHP-207. Wide lateral grooves channel water away to support hydroplaning resistance, while its 235/45ZR18 size and 18-inch rim specification define the wheel dimensions to check.

Lexani pairs its V-shaped tread with wide lateral grooves, connecting high-speed traction and braking aims with water evacuation for wet-road driving. A computer-optimized design lowers road noise and vibration, a practical benefit for drivers who want a quieter cabin alongside performance. The tire is intended for performance-oriented vehicles in warmer weather and carries a 50,000-mile limited manufacturer tread-life claim. Its 235/45ZR18 specification is the key sizing reference when checking a Model S configuration.

Skip it if you need an all-season 18-inch option; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS lists year-round traction and light-winter capability.

This suits a driver seeking a warm-weather performance tire with stated wet-water evacuation and cabin-noise features. Treat 235/45ZR18 as a sizing reference, not a guarantee of Model S fit; check the vehicle’s specified tire dimensions.

Listed on Amazon as: Lexani LXUHP-207 235/45ZR18 98W XL

#7

7. Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 245

• Size: 245/45ZR20 103Y
• Rim Size: 20 in
• Load Capacity: 1929 lb
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 245/45ZR20

Best for: Four-tire 20-inch replacement set.

Why it ranks #7: This four-tire set uses 245/45ZR20 103Y XL sizing, which may appeal to buyers checking a 20-inch setup; the listing provides few performance details.

A set of four is the Mastertrack M-TRAC HP listing’s key distinction, giving a buyer a complete quantity to consider in one purchase. These high-performance XL tires are specified as 245/45ZR20 103Y, a concrete 20-inch size and speed marking for comparison with a Model S setup.

Unlike listings for pairs, this one explicitly supplies four tires, which aligns with a buyer planning a full replacement rather than sourcing axles separately. The supplied specifications identify a 245/45ZR20 103Y size, 20-inch rim, XL designation in the title, and 1,929-pound load capacity. The title calls the tires high performance, but no additional wet-weather, seasonal, noise, or tread-life features are provided here to guide a more detailed performance comparison.

Skip it if you need a 275/40ZR20 pair rather than four tires; the Mastertrack M-TRAC HP set of two lists that size.

This package suits a buyer seeking four high-performance tires in the stated 245/45ZR20 size. The quantity simplifies a full-set purchase, but the Model S’s approved dimensions and load needs must match before this listing is appropriate.

Listed on Amazon as: Set of 4 Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 245/45ZR20 103Y XL High Performance Tires

#8

8. Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 275

• Size: 275/40ZR20
• Rim Size: 20 in
• Load Capacity: 2094 lb
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 275/40ZR20

Best for: 20-inch two-tire replacement pair.

Why it ranks #8: The two-tire set lists 275/40ZR20 XL sizing and a 2,094-pound load capacity, but the supplied listing gives no season or tread-life details.

This listing supplies a set of two Mastertrack M-TRAC HP tires in 275/40ZR20, giving buyers a clearly specified pair for a compatible 20-inch setup. The title identifies them as high-performance XL tires, with a 106W marking, so the listing provides several concrete specification points to compare.

The two-tire package is the central practical detail: it can serve a buyer seeking a pair, but it does not itself provide four tires for a full-car replacement. Mastertrack identifies the tires as high-performance and gives a 275/40ZR20 size, 20-inch rim specification, 106W marking, and 2,094-pound load capacity per the supplied specifications. Those details help narrow a comparison, but the listing supplies no specific wet-weather or tread-life claim to weigh.

Skip it if you need four tires in one listing; the set of four Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 245/45ZR20 is listed as a four-tire package.

This pair suits a buyer who needs two matching high-performance tires in the listed 275/40ZR20 size. Confirm the Model S’s required dimensions and load specification; buyers replacing all four should account for the package quantity.

Listed on Amazon as: Set of 2 Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 275/40ZR20 106W XL High Performance Tires

#9

9. Atlas Force UHP

• Size: 275/35R21
• Rim Size: 21 in
• Load Capacity: 1709 lb
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 275/35R21

Best for: 21-inch all-season tire pair.

Why it ranks #9: The 275/35R21 all-season tire has a stated 50,000-mile treadwear warranty, but the listing is a two-tire set and its size must be verified.

The Atlas Tire Force UHP listing combines an all-season designation with a 275/35R21 size, giving shoppers a specific 21-inch option to evaluate for a compatible passenger or crossover vehicle. It is sold as two tires, so the quantity is an important part of planning a Model S replacement.

Atlas describes the Force UHP as a performance or high-performance all-season tire for passenger vehicles, crossovers, and SUVs. That stated category makes it a candidate for buyers seeking an all-season option, while the 275/35R21 size and 21-inch rim specification define a narrow fit target. The listing offers two tires, not four, and the additional description states a 50,000-mile treadwear warranty. These details help with quantity and specification checks.

Skip it if you need four tires together in a 20-inch size; the Mastertrack M-TRAC HP set of four is listed in 245/45ZR20.

This pair suits a buyer whose vehicle calls for 275/35R21 all-season tires and who needs two rather than four. Check the exact Model S specification and account for the remaining tires if planning a full replacement.

Listed on Amazon as: 2 x Atlas Tire Force UHP 275/35R21 99W SL All Season Passenger Tires

#10

10. Horseshoe Sleipnir 2

• Size: 235/45ZR18 98Y XL
• Rim Size: 18 in
• Load Capacity: 1653 lb
• Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/45R18(F/R)

Best for: 18-inch all-season tire pair.

Why it ranks #10: Its 235/45R18 XL all-season sizing could match some setups, but the supplied details lack tread-life and performance information beyond a two-year warranty.

The HORSESHOE SLEIPNIR 2 listing identifies an ultra-high-performance all-season pair in 235/45ZR18, giving buyers a defined size and quantity to evaluate. Its title also specifies 98Y XL and 4-ply construction, details that help distinguish this option when comparing required tire specifications.

This listing contains two tires, which can suit a buyer replacing a pair but not someone expecting a complete four-tire set. The title calls the SLEIPNIR 2 an ultra-high-performance all-season radial and specifies 235/45ZR18 98Y XL, 4-ply, and M/S. The supplied specifications give a 1,653-pound load capacity and an 18-inch rim size. These are useful comparison details, but no further traction or tread-life performance claim is supplied.

Skip it if you need stated wet-traction and noise features; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS lists water-funneling grooves and reduced road noise.

This is for a buyer seeking two tires with the listed 235/45ZR18 98Y XL specification and all-season designation. Compare the stated dimensions and load capacity with the Model S requirements, and plan separately if replacing four tires.

Listed on Amazon as: HORSESHOE SLEIPNIR 2 New 235/45ZR18 235/45R18 98Y XL Andalusia Ultra High Performance Radial Tires 235 45 18 Load Range XL 4-Ply BSW M/S UHP All Season (2, 235/45ZR18 98Y XL)