Best Mudding Tires For Four Wheelers: Compare 10 Options

#1 · Best Overall

1. ITP Mud Lite XL 25-inch Set

• Size: 25×8-12, 25×10-12
• Rim Size: 12 in
• Load Capacity: 1235 lb

Best for: 25-inch XL four-tire set.

Why it ranks #1: A complete four-tire 25×8-12 and 25×10-12 pairing is listed with 6-ply XL tires, making it a practical mud-focused replacement set for 12-inch rims.

A matched front-and-rear size pairing makes this four-tire ITP Mud Lite XL bundle a clear option for 25-inch setups: it includes two 25×8-12 tires and two 25×10-12 tires. The listed 6-ply construction adds a specific build detail.

All four tires use 12-inch rims, with the narrower 25×8-12 and wider 25×10-12 sizes supplied together for the stated combination. The listing identifies both as ITP Mud Lite XL tires and specifies 6-ply construction, helping buyers compare the set by model, size, and construction. A 1,235-pound load capacity is given for the bundle, but the supplied facts do not break that figure down by tire or specify tread depth.

Skip it if you need a 26-inch XL combination; the Powersports Bundle 26×9-12 and 26×12-12 set lists those sizes.

This bundle suits ATV owners replacing four tires in the listed 25×8-12 and 25×10-12 XL combination. Its 12-inch rims and mixed widths are the main fit details, while the load figure is stated only for the bundle.

Listed on Amazon as: Full set of ITP Mud Lite XL 25×8-12 and 25×10-12 ATV Tires (4)

#2 · Mixed-Terrain Lugs

2. Tusk Mud Force Set

Best for: Mixed-terrain four-tire set.

Why it ranks #2: The complete 26×9-12 front and 26×11-12 rear set has 3/4-inch tread depth, open voids for soft surfaces, and connected lugs for firmer ground.

Open voids paired with stable, connected lugs give the TUSK Mud Force set its key mixed-surface distinction: the supplied facts describe traction on softer ground alongside handling on harder surfaces. Four tires arrive in 26×9-12 front and 26×11-12 rear sizes.

The specified front-and-rear sizes help buyers assess the set as a complete configuration, while its 3/4-inch tread depth and 6-ply rating provide two concrete construction details for comparison. TUSK describes the open voids as suited to softer surfaces and connected lugs as supporting handling on harder ground, connecting the tread layout to varied terrain use. The listing also supplies a long compatibility list, but vehicle fit still depends on the exact model and year shown there.

Skip it if you require four matching tire sizes; the Deestone D936 listing is a single 23X8.00-10 tire rather than a mixed-size set.

This set fits buyers seeking a four-tire, mixed-size setup for softer and harder surfaces, with listed compatibility across many ATV and UTV models. Check the exact vehicle entry and front/rear sizes before selecting it.

Listed on Amazon as: Tusk Mud Force UTV/ATV Tire Set of 4 26×9-12 Front & 26×11-12 Rear

#3 · Largest Listed Sizes

3. ITP Mud Lite II 27-inch Set

• Size: 27×9-12 , 27×11-12
• Rim Size: 12 in

Best for: Six-ply 27-inch set.

Why it ranks #3: This four-tire, 6-ply set pairs 27×9-12 fronts with 27×11-12 rears, suiting buyers whose ATV calls for these larger listed sizes.

This ITP Mud Lite II bundle provides four 27-inch tires in a 27×9-12 and 27×11-12 pairing, with 6-ply construction specified for both sizes. Its wider rear-size option makes the exact front-and-rear combination the central buying detail.

The package includes two 27×9-12 tires and two 27×11-12 tires, all for 12-inch rims, so it covers a four-tire replacement in the stated size combination. The listed 6-ply rating gives a construction detail to compare with other options. Because the supplied facts do not state tread depth, load capacity, or a vehicle compatibility list, buyers should base their assessment on the sizes and construction details provided rather than assume additional performance claims.

Skip it if you need stated tread-depth and load figures; the TUSK Mud Force set lists 3/4-inch tread depth and a 6-ply rating.

This bundle suits buyers seeking a four-tire ITP Mud Lite II set in 27×9-12 and 27×11-12 sizes. Its 12-inch rims and mixed widths define the fit considerations; the supplied facts do not include a vehicle-fit list.

Listed on Amazon as: Full set of ITP Mud Lite II (6ply) 27×9-12 and 27×11-12 ATV Tires (4)

#4

4. ITP Mud Lite XL 26-inch Set

• Size: 26×10-12 , 26×12-12
• Rim Size: 12 in

Best for: Mixed-size XL tire set.

Why it ranks #4: The complete XL set supplies two 26×10-12 and two 26×12-12 tires for 12-inch rims, though buyers should verify that unusual pairing matches their ATV.

The mixed 26-inch sizing is the defining feature of this four-tire ITP Mud Lite XL set: it pairs two 26×10-12 tires with two 26×12-12 tires. That gives buyers a complete set in a specified front-and-rear size combination, rather than four identical-width tires.

All four tires use 12-inch rims, while the two listed widths let you match the set to a vehicle setup calling for 26×10-12 and 26×12-12 sizes. The package quantity means you can source all four tires together. The supplied listing identifies the tires as Mud Lite XL, but gives no tread depth, ply rating, load capacity, or vehicle-fit list, so those details cannot be used to assess performance or compatibility.

Skip it if you need listed tread-depth or ply details before choosing; the ITP Mud Lite AT 25×10-12 listing specifies a 3/4-inch lug.

This set suits an ATV owner seeking four ITP Mud Lite XL tires in the listed 26×10-12 and 26×12-12 combination. Treat those sizes as the key boundary: the supplied facts do not provide a vehicle-specific fit list.

Listed on Amazon as: Full set of ITP Mud Lite XL 26×10-12 and 26×12-12 ATV Tires (4)

#5

5. ITP Mud Lite XL 26×9-12 Set

• Size: 26×9-12
• Rim Size: 12 in
• Load Capacity: 6836 lb

Best for: 26-inch XL mixed-size set.

Why it ranks #5: This four-tire XL bundle combines 26×9-12 and 26×12-12 sizes, and its listing identifies both tire sizes as 6-ply.

This four-tire ITP Mud Lite XL bundle pairs two 26×9-12 tires with two 26×12-12 tires, making its mixed-width 26-inch configuration the central feature. The package lists 6-ply construction and uses 12-inch rims for both tire sizes.

The four-tire quantity and explicit front-and-rear size pairing give buyers a single package for the stated configuration. Both sizes are identified as Mud Lite XL tires, with 6-ply construction specified in the bundle details. The 12-inch rim size helps clarify the wheel requirement, while the supplied listing reports a 6,836-pound load capacity for the bundle. It does not provide separate capacities by tire size or a tread-depth figure, so those details are not available for comparison.

Skip it if you need a 26×10-12 and 26×12-12 combination; the Powersports Bundle 26×10-12 and 26×12-12 set lists those sizes.

Choose this bundle if you need four ITP Mud Lite XL tires in the listed 26×9-12 and 26×12-12 combination. The mixed widths and 12-inch rims define the setup; separate load figures are not supplied.

Listed on Amazon as: Full set of ITP Mud Lite XL 26×9-12 and 26×12-12 ATV Tires (4)

#6 · Single Tire Pick

6. ITP Mud Lite AT 25×10-12

• Size: 25×10-12
• Rim Size: 12 in
• Load Capacity: 419 lb

Best for: Single 25-inch mud tire.

Why it ranks #6: The 25×10-12 mud-terrain tire has 3/4-inch lugs and a listed 419-pound load capacity, but it is a single tire rather than a full set.

A listed 3/4-inch lug depth gives the ITP Mud Lite AT 25×10-12 a concrete mud-tire feature to weigh: this single tire pairs that tread detail with a 12-inch rim size. It is a one-tire option, not a complete four-tire package.

The 25×10-12 size and 12-inch rim specification make this listing relevant when replacing one tire in that exact size. Its stated 419-pound load capacity gives buyers a listed load figure to consider alongside vehicle requirements, and the 19.2-pound item weight describes the tire itself. The 3/4-inch lug is the only supplied tread feature, so the data does not establish a broader tread pattern or a complete set configuration.

Skip it if you need four tires in one purchase; the TUSK Mud Force set includes four tires in its specified front and rear sizes.

Choose this ITP Mud Lite AT when you need a single 25×10-12 tire and value having its lug depth and load capacity stated. It is not the right package format for replacing all four tires at once.

Listed on Amazon as: ITP Mud Lite AT Mud Terrain ATV Tire 25×10-12

#7 · Deepest Listed Lugs

7. ITP Mud Lite XL 26×12-12

• Size: 26×12-12
• Rim Size: 12 in
• Load Capacity: 1070 lb

Best for: Deep-lug XL single tire.

Why it ranks #7: Its stated 1-1/8-inch lugs and 6-ply construction target demanding loose terrain, but the listing is for one 26×12-12 tire only.

Deep 1-1/8-inch lugs distinguish the ITP Mud Lite XL 26×12.00-12, with the listing connecting its aggressive tread to traction and control on mud, rocky paths, and challenging trails. This is one tire, with a stated 6-ply rating.

The 26×12-12 size and 12-inch rim specification help buyers assess whether the tire matches their setup, while its 6-ply-rated construction and 1,070-pound listed load capacity provide concrete comparison points. The product description also names loose and soft surfaces, rocky terrain, and snow-covered roads as intended terrain contexts. Because the listing is for a tire only, a full replacement requires sourcing the remaining tires separately in suitable sizes.

Skip it if you need four XL tires together; the Powersports Bundle 26×9-12 and 26×12-12 listing includes four.

Choose this single Mud Lite XL tire if you need the 26×12-12 size and want its deep lugs, 6-ply rating, and load capacity stated. The tire-only format means it does not supply a complete set.

Listed on Amazon as: ITP Mud Lite XL 26X12.00-12 C/6PLY ATV & UTV Tire

#8

8. MaxAuto 25-inch Mud Sand Set

• Size: 25×8-12 Front & 25×10-12 Rear
• Rim Size: 12 in
• Load Capacity: 4.8E+2 lb

Best for: Six-ply mixed-size set.

Why it ranks #8: The four-tire tubeless set uses 25×8-12 fronts and 25×10-12 rears, with 6 PR construction and stated tread depths of 15 and 15.5 mm.

The MaxAuto four-tire set combines 6PR construction with 25×8-12 front and 25×10-12 rear mud-and-sand sizes. That pairing gives buyers a complete, position-specific package, while the supplied load figures distinguish the narrower front tires from the wider rear tires.

The 25×8-12 fronts are listed with a 395-pound maximum load at 10 psi and a 6.5-inch rim width; the 25×10-12 rears list 480 pounds at 10 psi and an 8-inch rim width. Those figures let buyers assess each position rather than treating the set as four identical tires. The tubeless construction is specified, and the package is divided into two individual packages. The listing states these tires are not for highway service.

Skip it if you need tires for highway service; the TUSK Mud Force set listing describes a mixed soft- and hard-surface tread design.

This set suits buyers looking for tubeless mud-and-sand tires in a 25-inch front/rear combination, with separate load and rim-width figures. Its not-for-highway-service notice makes it an off-road choice, not a road-going tire.

Listed on Amazon as: MaxAuto Set of 4 AT25x8-12 & AT25x10-12 ATV UTV Mud Sand Tires,25x8x12 Front & 25x10x12 Rear All-Terrain Off-Road Tires,6 PR, Tubeless,4 Pack in 2 Packages

#9

9. REALLYCNC TRS 25-inch Set

• Size: 25x8x10-12-new
• Rim Size: 12 in
• Load Capacity: 340 lb

Best for: Tubeless 25-inch tire set.

Why it ranks #9: This four-tire tubeless 25×8-12 and 25×10-12 set lists 20 mm tread depth and a two-year manufacturer warranty, but its mud-specific details are limited.

A tubeless four-tire package combines 25×8-12 and 25×10-12 sizes in this REALLYCNC set, giving buyers a stated front-and-rear combination in one listing. Both sizes specify 20 mm of tread depth, a useful common detail when comparing the pair.

The set includes four tires for 12-inch rims, with 25×8-12 and 25×10-12 sizes and a stated 7-inch rim width for each. The listing gives different load figures at 7 psi—340 pounds for the narrower tire and 420 pounds for the wider one—so buyers can consider each position separately. It also describes a tread compound intended to enhance puncture resistance and tire life, though the supplied details do not quantify either outcome.

Skip it if you need a set with a stated 6-ply rating; the MaxAuto 25×8-12 and 25×10-12 set lists 6PR.

Consider this set if you want four tubeless tires in a 25-inch mixed-size configuration and value listed tread depth and load figures. Its stated 7-inch rim width is an important setup detail to check against your needs.

Listed on Amazon as: 25×8-12 & 25×10-12 ATV UTV Tires TRS (Pack of 4, Tubeless)

#10

10. Deestone D936 Mud Crusher

• Size: 23X8.00-10
• Rim Size: 10 in
• Load Capacity: 300 lb

Best for: Single deep-mud tire.

Why it ranks #10: Its directional lugs are described for soft and loose terrain, especially deeper mud, but this is one 23X8.00-10 tire, not a four-tire set.

Directional tread and large lugs are the Deestone D936 Mud Crusher’s defining mud-terrain features, with the supplied description specifically noting traction on soft and loose ground, especially deeper mud. It is a single 23X8.00-10 tire for a 10-inch rim.

The 23X8.00-10 size and 10-inch rim specification help narrow fit considerations, while the 6-ply construction is a stated detail for buyers comparing tire builds. Deestone identifies it as an all-season, bias tire for ATVs and UTVs. Its directional tread and large lugs are described as finding traction on soft and loose surfaces, making the tread design relevant to muddy use. The listed load capacity is 300 pounds, so buyers can check that figure against their requirements.

Skip it if you need a four-tire package; the Deestone listing supplies one tire, while the REALLYCNC TRS listing includes four.

Pick the D936 when you need one 23X8.00-10 tire for ATV or UTV use and prioritize its stated directional lug tread for loose ground. The single-tire format and 300-pound load figure are key boundaries.

Listed on Amazon as: Deestone D936 Mud Crusher 23X8.00-10 Mud Terrain 6 Ply All Season Bias Tire