A strong roof-storage choice adds useful luggage space, fits your vehicle’s roof setup, and secures gear with the right straps or mounting hardware. These options suit drivers who need room for road-trip bags, camping equipment, or other cargo without using the passenger cabin. The list compares soft bags from 15 to 35 cubic feet, hard-shell boxes, and a basket-and-bag bundle.
Some soft bags are advertised for vehicles with or without roof racks, while the hard-shell options have specific rack-fit requirements to check. Capacity is only part of the decision: dimensions, material, included anti-slip mats or hooks, and access style also matter.
Use the product details below to narrow the field, then confirm your vehicle’s roof limits and the maker’s fit guidance before installing any carrier.
The Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag is the best overall choice here because its 840D PVC construction, triple-reinforced welded seams, waterproof zipper flap, and included anti-slip mat and six door hooks address key needs for a soft car-top carrier. Its 52-by-40-by-18-inch dimensions provide a useful reference for checking roof fit. If you need substantially more volume, the Mockins 35-Cubic-Foot Bag offers the largest listed capacity, but its larger dimensions make vehicle clearance and fit checks especially important.
Our Top Picks
Best OverallAsinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
Its 21-cubic-foot capacity, 840D PVC, welded seams, zipper flap, anti-slip mat, and six door hooks make it a well-equipped soft carrier.
View on Amazon
Highest CapacityThe 35-cubic-foot capacity is the largest listed, and the included mat, door hooks, straps, and stated rack-free use add flexibility.
View on Amazon
Thicker PVCAsinking 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
This 20-cubic-foot bag uses 900D double-coated PVC and includes a non-slip mat, combination lock, storage bag, and four anti-scratch door hooks.
View on Amazon- Rear-Opening Box SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box
- Hard-Shell Pick D SOLUTIONS 11-Cubic-Foot Box
Compare roof storage options and their key differences
| # | Product | Dimensions | Weight | Material | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1. Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof BagBest Overall | 52"L x 40"W x 18"H | 4.24 kg | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) | View on Amazon |
| 2 | 2. Mockins 35-Cubic-Foot BagHighest Capacity | 60"L x 42"W x 24"H | 15.5 lb | Heavy Duty Abrasion-Resistant Vinyl | View on Amazon |
| 3 | 3. Asinking 20-Cubic-Foot Roof BagThicker PVC | 40"L x 52"W x 18.5"H | 2.39 kg | 900D Double-Coated Abraison-Resistant PVC… | View on Amazon |
| 4 | 4. MeeFar 20-Cubic-Foot Roof BagQuick-install soft-bag travelers | 51"L x 40"W x 17"H | 3.9 kg | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) | View on Amazon |
| 5 | 5. MIDABAO 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag20-cubic-foot soft-bag users | 51.1"L x 39"W x 17"H | 3.94 kg | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) Nylon | View on Amazon |
| 6 | 6. DUMOS 15-Cubic-Foot Roof BagCompact weather-protection seekers | 44"L x 34"W x 17"H | 8 lb | Polyester, Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) | View on Amazon |
| 7 | 7. reemplazo 21-Cubic-Foot Roof BagMulti-vehicle soft-bag shoppers | — | — | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) | View on Amazon |
| 8 | 8. SportRack Vista XL Cargo BoxRear-Opening Box | — | — | Plastic | View on Amazon |
| 9 | 9. D SOLUTIONS 11-Cubic-Foot BoxHard-Shell Pick | 53"L x 34"W x 15"H | 50.3 lb | ABS Plastic | View on Amazon |
| 10 | 10. Mockins Roof Rack BundleCrossbar-equipped gear haulers | 53"L x 40"W x 17"H | 45 lb | 840D Abrasion-Resistant Vinyl | View on Amazon |
Detailed Reviews: Best Roof Storage For Cars

#1 · Best Overall
1. Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
- Dimensions: 52"L x 40"W x 18"H
- Weight: 4.24 kg
- Material: Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)
Best for: Rain-conscious soft-bag travelers.
Why it ranks #1: Its 21-cubic-foot capacity, 840D PVC, welded seams, zipper flap, anti-slip mat, and six door hooks make it a well-equipped soft carrier.
Triple-reinforced welded seams pair with heavy-duty 840D abrasion-resistant PVC in Asinking’s 21-cubic-foot roof bag, giving travelers a soft carrier with reinforced construction and weather protection. Its waterproof zipper is covered by six-inch-wide Velcro flaps, an arrangement intended to help keep rain from reaching packed luggage during trips.
The 52-by-40-by-18-inch bag offers substantial space for luggage while remaining a soft-shell carrier. Its 840D PVC fabric is abrasion-resistant, and triple-reinforced welded seams add durability while helping prevent rain leaking through the seams. A waterproof zipper and widened Velcro flaps provide another barrier over the opening. This combination suits travelers who want a weather-focused bag rather than a rigid box; the supplied details do not specify included mounting hardware, so the listed construction is the clearest buying distinction.
- 21 cubic feet of listed storage capacity
- Heavy-duty 840D abrasion-resistant PVC fabric
- Triple-reinforced welded seams help prevent seam leaks
- Waterproof zipper with six-inch-wide Velcro flaps
- The supplied product details do not specify included mounting hardware.
Skip it if you need a listed installation kit with hooks and a mat; MeeFar’s XBEEK includes those accessories.
Choose this Asinking bag if weather protection and reinforced seams matter for carrying luggage on the roof. Its 21-cubic-foot soft format offers room for trip gear, but buyers wanting specified mounting accessories should consider that its supplied listing does not detail them.
Full product details
| Brand | Asinking |
|---|---|
| Color | Black |
| Dimensions | 52"L x 40"W x 18"H |
| Item Weight | 4.24 kg |
| Manufacturer | Asinking |
| Part Number | Rooftop Cargo Carrier |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | Heavy duty waterproof 840D PVC tear-resistant fabric |
| Material | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) |
| Model Number | Black |

#2 · Highest Capacity
2. Mockins 35-Cubic-Foot Bag
- Dimensions: 60"L x 42"W x 24"H
- Weight: 15.5 lb
- Material: Heavy Duty Abrasion-Resistant Vinyl
Best for: Oversized-load road trippers.
Why it ranks #2: The 35-cubic-foot capacity is the largest listed, and the included mat, door hooks, straps, and stated rack-free use add flexibility.
With 35 cubic feet of space and dimensions of 60 by 42 by 24 inches, Mockins’ XL soft bag accommodates oversized trip loads such as suitcases, tents, and sleeping bags. Its listed 250-pound capacity and compatibility with racks or rack-free use offer flexibility for vehicles and gear configurations.
The heavy-duty abrasion-resistant vinyl bag can mount on crossbars, side rails, and racks, or be used without a roof rack, giving buyers several stated setup options. The package includes a roof mat, storage bag, lock, buckle straps, ratchet straps, trunk hooks, and door hooks, supporting positioning and restraint with supplied accessories. Its 35-cubic-foot capacity and 250-pound stated load limit suit bulky cargo, while the 24-inch height makes it a notably large rooftop package to account for when loading.
- 35 cubic feet of storage in a 60-by-42-by-24-inch bag
- Stated capacity of up to 250 pounds
- Listed for crossbars, side rails, racks, or rack-free use
- Includes roof mat, storage bag, lock, hooks, and multiple straps
- Its 24-inch height makes it a tall rooftop load.
Skip it if you need a rigid box with rear-opening access; SportRack Vista XL uses a hard shell and opens away from traffic.
This Mockins XL bag fits road trippers, campers, and movers carrying bulky loads who want rack and rack-free setup options. Its 24-inch height and large footprint are important boundaries when planning rooftop clearance and loading.
Full product details
| Brand | Mockins |
|---|---|
| Color | Black |
| Included Components | 1 x 35 Cubic Ft XL Waterproof Roof Cargo Bag with 1 x Bag Lock, 1 x Car Roof Mat and 1 x Storage Bag, 2 x Long Buckle Straps and 4 x Short Buckle Straps, 2 x Trunk Hooks and 6 x Door Hooks, 3 x Ratchet Straps |
| Dimensions | 60"L x 42"W x 24"H |
| Item Weight | 15.5 pounds |
| Manufacturer | Mockins |
| Part Number | MA-RB-35BLK-60X42-17-V2 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 10 Year Limited Warranty |
| Material | Heavy Duty Abrasion-Resistant Vinyl |
| Model Number | MA-RB-35BLK-60X42-17-V2 |
| Additional Information | Important Information Proposition 65 Warning for California Consumers WARNING: This product can expose you to chemicals including di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP) which is known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov |
Listed on Amazon as: Mockins 35 Cu Ft XL Black Soft Shell Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag 60"x42"x24"
View on Amazon
#3 · Thicker PVC
3. Asinking 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
- Dimensions: 40"L x 52"W x 18.5"H
- Weight: 2.39 kg
- Material: 900D Double-Coated Abraison-Resistant PVC…
Best for: Rack-free-compatible soft-bag buyers.
Why it ranks #3: This 20-cubic-foot bag uses 900D double-coated PVC and includes a non-slip mat, combination lock, storage bag, and four anti-scratch door hooks.
A 20-cubic-foot capacity and stated compatibility with vehicles both with and without roof racks make this Asinking bag flexible for varied vehicle setups. Its included non-slip mat, combination lock, storage bag, and four anti-scratch door hooks give buyers useful packing and attachment accessories in one soft-carrier package.
The bag measures 40 by 52 by 18.5 inches and uses 900D double-coated abrasion-resistant PVC-laminated tarpaulin. That material specification supports buyers seeking a heavier-duty soft-shell fabric, while the included mat and four door hooks provide components for positioning and attachment. The combination lock adds a listed way to secure the carrier, and the storage bag gives the soft item a place to go between trips. The supplied information identifies broad vehicle compatibility but does not give a detailed mounting procedure.
- 20 cubic feet of listed storage
- 900D double-coated abrasion-resistant PVC-laminated tarpaulin
- Stated compatibility with vehicles with or without roof racks
- Includes non-slip mat, combination lock, storage bag, and four door hooks
- The supplied details do not specify a waterproof construction claim for this model.
Skip it if you require an explicitly stated waterproof rating; Asinking’s 840D bag lists waterproof zipper protection and reinforced seams.
Choose this Asinking model if rack flexibility, 900D fabric, and included hooks and mat suit your vehicle and packing needs. The listing does not state a waterproof claim for this model, so weather protection should be a deciding boundary.
Full product details
| Brand | Asinking |
|---|---|
| Color | Black with Orange |
| Included Components | 1x 20 cubic feet waterproof vehicle soft-shell carriers, 1x combination lock, 1x non-slip mat, 1x storage bag, 4x anti-scratch door hooks |
| Dimensions | 40"L x 52"W x 18.5"H |
| Item Weight | 2.39 kg |
| Manufacturer | Asinking |
| Part Number | rooftop cargo carrier |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 2-Year Warranty for All Quality Issues |
| Material | 900D Double-Coated Abraison-Resistant PVC Laminated Tarpaulin |
| Model Number | car roof cargo carrier |
Listed on Amazon as: Car Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag 100% Waterproof 20 Cu Ft Roof Bag
View on Amazon
#4
4. MeeFar 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
- Dimensions: 51"L x 40"W x 17"H
- Weight: 3.9 kg
- Material: Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)
Best for: Quick-install soft-bag travelers.
Why it ranks #4: Its 20-cubic-foot capacity, 700D PVC tarpaulin, anti-slip mat, luggage lock, and six security hooks suit buyers seeking a complete soft-bag kit.
A supplied anti-slip mat, six security hooks, luggage lock, and storage bag make the MeeFar XBEEK a practical 20-cubic-foot soft carrier package. The listed accessories support a straightforward installation and securing workflow, while the foldable soft shell stores compactly between trips instead of occupying the space required by a rigid roof box.
The 51-by-40-by-17-inch bag is made from 700D PVC tarpaulin, described as waterproof and tearproof. Its zipper cover is stated to help protect contents in heavy rain, while ten built-in straps and six extra straps help keep cargo in place. The anti-slip mat and six security hooks are included for setup, and the soft shell folds into its storage bag after use. The combination suits drivers seeking a complete, stowable carrier kit.
- 20 cubic feet of storage in a 51-by-40-by-17-inch bag
- 700D PVC tarpaulin described as waterproof and tearproof
- Includes anti-slip mat, six security hooks, and luggage lock
- Folds into the included storage bag when not in use
- A soft shell offers less rigid structure than a hard cargo box.
Skip it if you need rigid, rear-opening access to luggage; SportRack Vista XL provides a hard ABS box with rear opening.
The MeeFar XBEEK suits travelers who want a fold-away 20-cubic-foot bag with installation and securing accessories included. Choose it for soft-shell storage and compact stowing; drivers prioritizing rigid construction and rear access may prefer a box.
Full product details
| Brand | MeeFar |
|---|---|
| Color | Black |
| Folded Size | Compact |
| Included Components | Comes with housing |
| Dimensions | 51"L x 40"W x 17"H |
| Item Weight | 3.9 kg |
| Manufacturer | MeeFar |
| Part Number | MF-1002 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 60 days |
| Material | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) |
| Model Number | 20 Cubic Feet |
Listed on Amazon as: Car Roof Bag Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag Waterproof 20 Cubic Feet roof Cargo
View on Amazon
#5
5. MIDABAO 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
- Dimensions: 51.1"L x 39"W x 17"H
- Weight: 3.94 kg
- Material: Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) Nylon
Best for: 20-cubic-foot soft-bag users.
Why it ranks #5: This 20-cubic-foot PVC-and-nylon bag is listed for cars with or without racks and measures 51.1 by 39 by 17 inches.
MIDABAO’s 20-cubic-foot soft roof bag measures 51.1 by 39 by 17 inches and is listed for cars with or without roof racks. That combination gives travelers a generous stated cargo volume in a flexible bag format, with an anti-slip mat included for positioning on the vehicle roof.
The PVC-and-nylon carrier’s listed dimensions help buyers compare its footprint with their roof and packed luggage, while its 20-cubic-foot capacity provides extra cargo room. The product title identifies coated zippers and waterproof construction, useful details for travelers concerned about wet-weather storage. Its with-or-without-rack compatibility broadens the stated vehicle setups, and the supplied anti-slip mat is a practical part of placement. The listing does not detail a complete attachment kit, so buyers should weigh that against the features explicitly provided.
- 20 cubic feet of stated cargo capacity
- 51.1-by-39-by-17-inch overall dimensions
- Listed for vehicles with or without roof racks
- Waterproof construction and coated zippers stated in the title
- The supplied listing identifies an anti-slip mat but does not detail other attachment hardware.
Skip it if you want a listed set of door hooks and multiple straps; Mockins’ 35-cubic-foot bag includes both.
This MIDABAO bag suits drivers seeking 20 cubic feet of soft rooftop storage and compatibility with or without racks. Its stated waterproof build and included mat are useful, while the limited attachment details are an important purchase consideration.
Full product details
| Brand | MIDABAO |
|---|---|
| Color | BLACK |
| Included Components | Comes with housing |
| Dimensions | 51.1"L x 39"W x 17"H |
| Item Weight | 3.94 kg |
| Manufacturer | MIDABAO |
| Part Number | M-02-02 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 1 |
| Material | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) Nylon |
| Model Number | M-02 |
Listed on Amazon as: 20 Cubic Waterproof Duty Car Roof Top Carrier-Car Cargo Roof Top Bag, Waterproof & Coated Zippers includes Anti Slip Mat with or without Racks (20 Cubic Feet)
View on Amazon
#6
6. DUMOS 15-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
- Dimensions: 44"L x 34"W x 17"H
- Weight: 8 lb
- Material: Polyester, Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)
Best for: Compact weather-protection seekers.
Why it ranks #6: The 15-cubic-foot capacity is smaller, but its listed waterproof PVC, sealed seams, anti-slip mat, door hooks, lock, and reinforced straps add practical details.
Sealed seams and stated 100% waterproof, tearproof heavy-duty PVC distinguish the DUMOS 15-cubic-foot roof bag for travelers protecting luggage from rain and snow. Its smaller capacity than many larger listed bags can suit buyers who want added roof storage without choosing the biggest available soft carrier.
At 44 by 34 by 17 inches, the bag offers 15 cubic feet for suitcases, sleeping bags, and tents, according to its product details. Enhanced sealed seams work alongside its waterproof PVC construction to help keep cargo dry, while the anti-slip mat and reinforced straps are included for setup and restraint. Door hooks and a luggage lock also come with the package. This provides a defined accessory set, though the listed capacity is best matched to more moderate loads than oversized packing needs.
- 15 cubic feet of storage in a 44-by-34-by-17-inch bag
- Stated 100% waterproof and tearproof heavy-duty PVC
- Enhanced sealed seams help protect cargo
- Includes anti-slip mat, door hooks, luggage lock, and reinforced straps
- Its 15-cubic-foot capacity is smaller than 20- and 21-cubic-foot bags.
Skip it if you need 20 cubic feet or more; MIDABAO’s 20-cubic-foot bag offers additional listed storage volume.
Choose the DUMOS bag if sealed, waterproof construction and its included mat, hooks, lock, and straps suit your trip. Its 15-cubic-foot capacity sets the boundary for buyers packing larger loads or multiple bulky items.
Full product details
| Brand | DUMOS |
|---|---|
| Color | Black Orange |
| Included Components | Anti-Slip Mat, Door Hooks, Luggage Lock, Reinforced Straps |
| Dimensions | 44"L x 34"W x 17"H |
| Item Weight | 8 pounds |
| Manufacturer | DUMOS |
| Part Number | LCDU-TA-CDB4514 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | No |
| Material | Polyester, Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) |
| Model Number | TA-CDB4514-15-BY |
Listed on Amazon as: DUMOS Car Roof Bag Cargo Carrier Waterproof 15 Cubic Feet for All Vehicles
View on Amazon
#7
7. reemplazo 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag
- Material: Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)
Best for: Multi-vehicle soft-bag shoppers.
Why it ranks #7: Its 21-cubic-foot capacity and stated compatibility with several roof types are useful, though the supplied details identify fewer construction specifics.
A stated 21 cubic feet of storage and compatibility with cars, SUVs, trucks, sedans, hatchbacks, and wagons make this reemplazo bag a versatile soft-carrier option. Its listing also covers vehicles with or without factory racks or side rails, enabling roof storage across several common vehicle and roof configurations.
The bag is made from PVC and described as waterproof, tear-resistant, heavy-duty, and easy to install. Its included non-slip mat and six door hooks support positioning and attachment, while the listing says no extra mounting tools are required. Capacity of 21 cubic feet provides room for luggage and camping supplies, and the stated fit spans roof setups including side rails, crossbars, and baskets or trays. The supplied facts do not state the bag’s dimensions, so volume is the main packing reference.
- 21 cubic feet of listed storage capacity
- Stated compatibility with cars, SUVs, trucks, sedans, hatchbacks, and wagons
- Listed for vehicles with or without racks or side rails
- Includes non-slip mat and six door hooks; no extra mounting tools required
- The supplied specifications do not list the bag’s overall dimensions.
Skip it if you need listed dimensions to compare the bag with your roof; DUMOS provides a 44-by-34-by-17-inch specification.
This reemplazo bag suits travelers seeking 21 cubic feet of soft storage across several vehicle and roof types, with a mat and hooks included. Buyers who need exact exterior measurements for roof planning should note that dimensions are not supplied.
Full product details
| Brand | reemplazo |
|---|---|
| Color | Black Gray |
| Included Components | Car Rooftop Bag |
| Manufacturer | reemplazo |
| Part Number | RoofBag-BlackGray |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 1 Year Manufacturer |
| Material | Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) |
| Model Number | RoofBag-BlackGray |
Listed on Amazon as: Car Roof Rooftop Cargo Carrier Bag Waterproof Luggage Storage 21 Cubic Feet, Soft Shell Large Roof Top Cargo Bag Heavy Duty Travel for SUV Pickup Truck with/Without Roof Racks (Black Gray)
View on Amazon
#8 · Rear-Opening Box
8. SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box
- Material: Plastic
Best for: Rear-access hard-box shoppers.
Why it ranks #8: The rigid 18-cubic-foot ABS box has a lock and rear opening, plus compatibility with several rack styles subject to its fit guide.
A rear-opening design lets drivers reach the SportRack Vista XL’s 18 cubic feet of cargo away from traffic, a practical advantage when loading or retrieving items roadside. Its UV-resistant ABS construction forms a rigid enclosure, while the included lock secures both contents and the box to the rack.
The 62.5-by-39-by-19-inch box provides 18 cubic feet of internal storage and a stated 100-pound load capacity. Rear opening keeps access at the back of the vehicle rather than beside passing traffic, while tool-free mounting hardware supports installation and removal. The box fits SportRack systems, square and round bars, and most factory racks, although the product listing directs buyers to its fit guide. UV-resistant ABS and the included lock add durability and security features for stored gear.
- 18 cubic feet of internal cargo capacity
- Rear opening provides access away from traffic
- UV-resistant ABS construction
- Includes tool-free mounting hardware and a lock
- The stated load capacity is limited to 100 pounds.
Skip it if you need more than 100 pounds of listed load capacity; Mockins’ cargo basket states a 250-pound limit.
Choose the Vista XL if rear access away from traffic and a lockable hard box suit your travel routine. Its 18-cubic-foot capacity and 100-pound load limit define the fit, and rack compatibility remains a key setup consideration.
Full product details
| Brand | SportRack |
|---|---|
| Color | Black |
| Included Components | Roof Box and mounting hardware |
| Item Dimensions | 62.5 x 39 x 19 inches |
| Dimensions | 62.5 x 39 x 19 inches |
| Load Capacity | 100 pounds |
| Manufacturer | Thule, Inc. |
| Part Number | SR7018 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 25 years |
| Material | Plastic |
| Model Number | SR7018 |
| Additional Information | Important information |
Listed on Amazon as: SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box,Black
View on Amazon
#9 · Hard-Shell Pick
9. D SOLUTIONS 11-Cubic-Foot Box
- Dimensions: 53"L x 34"W x 15"H
- Weight: 50.3 lb
- Material: ABS Plastic
Best for: Crossbar owners wanting a hard box.
Why it ranks #9: Its UV-stabilized ABS shell is described as weatherproof, while the 11-cubic-foot capacity and maximum 13-inch crossbar width make fit checks essential.
Tool-free assembly and quick installation distinguish this 11-cubic-foot hard-shell box, enabling roof storage without a tool-based setup. Its UV-stabilized, weatherproof ABS construction is described as shielding gear from rain, sunlight, snow, and minor impacts, giving travelers a rigid enclosure for exposed rooftop loads.
The 53-by-34-by-15-inch box provides 11 cubic feet of luggage space in a hard ABS shell, so cargo sits inside a structured enclosure rather than a soft bag. The maker specifies mounting to crossbars up to 13 inches wide and calls assembly tool-free, linking compatibility and setup to the buyer’s roof configuration. UV stabilization and weatherproof construction are intended to protect contents from sun and precipitation. Check the stated crossbar-width limit against your rack before choosing it.
- 11 cubic feet of hard-shell storage
- UV-stabilized, weatherproof ABS construction
- Described protection from rain, sunlight, snow, and minor impacts
- Tool-free assembly and quick installation
- Mounting is limited to crossbars no wider than 13 inches.
Skip it if you need more than 11 cubic feet or a carrier that works without crossbars; Mockins’ 35-cubic-foot soft bag supports rack-free use.
Choose this D SOLUTIONS box if you want a rigid, weatherproof enclosure and your crossbars meet its 13-inch maximum width. Its 11-cubic-foot capacity is the boundary for buyers packing bulkier loads or seeking a larger soft carrier.
Full product details
| Brand | D SOLUTIONS |
|---|---|
| Color | Textured Black |
| Included Components | Rooftop Box Cargo Carrier |
| Dimensions | 53"L x 34"W x 15"H |
| Item Weight | 50.3 pounds |
| Manufacturer | D SOLUTIONS |
| Part Number | D64342S |
| Material | ABS Plastic |
Listed on Amazon as: Hard Shell Rooftop Cargo Carrier, 11Cubic Ft Waterproof Travel Luggage Box
View on Amazon
#10
10. Mockins Roof Rack Bundle
- Dimensions: 53"L x 40"W x 17"H
- Weight: 45 lb
- Material: 840D Abrasion-Resistant Vinyl
Best for: Crossbar-equipped gear haulers.
Why it ranks #10: This crossbar-mounted basket bundle includes a cargo bag and net, but its listed rack-focused setup is less direct than the standalone soft carriers.
A 250-pound stated capacity and extendable steel cargo basket give the Mockins carrier room for substantial roof loads, while its included cargo bag adds an enclosed option. For drivers with crossbars, the basket-and-bag combination supports carrying gear in an open rack or using the supplied soft storage component.
The package lists a roof basket with extension, rooftop cargo bag, cargo net, carry bag, and securing straps, so buyers receive several ways to organize and restrain loads. Its weatherproof, rust-resistant steel basket is described as suitable for roof-rack mounting, and a wind deflector is intended to reduce drag, noise, and fuel use. The listed load limit is 250 pounds. At approximately 34 pounds in the feature description, the carrier itself is a substantial item to handle during installation.
- Stated load capacity of up to 250 pounds
- Extendable steel basket with weatherproof, rust-resistant construction
- Includes cargo bag, cargo net, carry bag, and securing straps
- Wind deflector is intended to reduce drag and noise
- Requires a crossbar-equipped vehicle for the listed mounting setup.
Skip it if you have no crossbars and want a carrier explicitly listed for rack-free use; Mockins’ 35-cubic-foot soft bag offers that option.
This Mockins combination suits crossbar-equipped drivers carrying bulky gear who value both an open basket and an included cargo bag. Its listed mounting depends on crossbars, so it is not the choice for a rack-free installation.
Full product details
| Brand | Mockins |
|---|---|
| Color | Black |
| Included Components | 1 x Cargo Net, 1 x Carry Bag, 1 x Roof Cargo Basket with Extension, 1 x Rooftop Cargo Bag and 1 x Bag Combo Lock, 4 x Buckle Straps 2 x Ratchet Straps |
| Dimensions | 53"L x 40"W x 17"H |
| Item Weight | 45 pounds |
| Manufacturer | Mockins |
| Part Number | 819867024100 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 5 Year Limited Warranty |
| Material | 840D Abrasion-Resistant Vinyl |
| Additional Information | Important Information Proposition 65 Warning for California Consumers WARNING: This product can expose you to chemicals including di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP) which is known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov |
Listed on Amazon as: Mockins 64"x39"x5" Extendable Roof Rack Cargo Carrier for Top of Vehicle
View on AmazonWhere roof bags can fail in bad weather
A soft roof bag’s closure and seams are potential weak points, so weather claims should be read alongside the construction details. The Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag specifies triple-reinforced welded seams and a waterproof zipper covered by widened hook-and-loop flaps; those details address paths where water might enter. The MeeFar 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag also describes a zipper cover for heavy rain, while the DUMOS 15-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag cites enhanced sealed seams.
These descriptions are not independent test results, and no supplied product data establishes performance in every storm or at highway speed. Pack moisture-sensitive items in their own protective bags, close and secure the carrier as directed, and check straps and closures during stops.
A rigid box such as the SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box avoids a flexible bag closure, but its listing likewise does not provide a waterproof test rating.
Check roof fit beyond the bag’s stated capacity
A capacity figure does not confirm that a carrier will fit your roof or clear the vehicle’s doors and rear hatch. Compare the carrier’s dimensions with the usable roof area, and follow the vehicle and carrier makers’ load and mounting instructions. The D SOLUTIONS 11-Cubic-Foot Box gives a specific maximum crossbar width of 13 inches, making bar measurements a necessary check.
The SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box lists compatible rack styles and a crossbar-spacing range in its product details, so consult its fit guide rather than assuming universal fit. Soft bags may offer more mounting flexibility: several options are advertised for cars with or without racks and include door hooks or straps.
That flexibility does not guarantee a safe fit on every vehicle. Verify that the intended attachment points are allowed and that the loaded carrier will not interfere with doors, visibility, or vehicle operation.
How to Choose Car Roof Storage
Capacity and overall dimensions
Choose capacity around the gear you actually need to move, then check the carrier’s dimensions against your roof. Listed soft-bag capacities range from the DUMOS 15-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag to the Mockins 35-Cubic-Foot Bag; several options sit at 20 or 21 cubic feet. The Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag measures 52 by 40 by 18 inches, while the larger Mockins measures 60 by 42 by 24 inches.
A smaller bag can suit occasional luggage or a vehicle with limited roof space; the 35-cubic-foot option is aimed at oversized loads, subject to fit and vehicle limits. The SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box offers 18 cubic feet in a rigid format.
Do not treat capacity as a measure of safe roof load.
Roof attachment and vehicle compatibility
Match the carrier’s mounting method to your vehicle’s roof and confirm the exact fit before buying. Several soft bags, including the Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag and MIDABAO 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag, are described for vehicles with or without racks; listed accessories include door hooks, straps, or an anti-slip mat. The Mockins 35-Cubic-Foot Bag also describes use on crossbars, side rails, racks, or without a roof rack.
By contrast, the D SOLUTIONS 11-Cubic-Foot Box requires crossbars no wider than 13 inches, and the SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box lists rack compatibility subject to a fit guide. Drivers without crossbars may prefer a compatible soft-bag setup; drivers with crossbars can consider a box or basket, but should verify spacing and load limits.
Material and weather protection details
Look for specific material and closure details rather than relying on a broad weather-protection label. The Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag lists 840D PVC, welded seams, and a covered waterproof zipper; the Asinking 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag lists 900D double-coated PVC. MeeFar specifies 700D PVC tarpaulin, while SportRack describes its 18-cubic-foot box as UV-resistant ABS and D SOLUTIONS identifies UV-stabilized, weatherproof ABS.
These are different constructions, not comparable test results. A soft bag may be easier to fold and store, while a rigid box keeps its shape; the product data does not establish that one format is universally more weatherproof.
Frequent travelers who prioritize specified seam and zipper features may favor the Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag; those preferring a hard shell can examine the two boxes and confirm their rack fit.
Which car roof storage should you choose?
For a balanced soft-bag setup, choose the Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag: it combines 840D PVC, reinforced welded seams, a covered zipper, an anti-slip mat, and six door hooks. If carrying the most listed volume matters, the Mockins 35-Cubic-Foot Bag offers 35 cubic feet and includes mounting accessories, but check its 60-by-42-by-24-inch size against your vehicle. For a 20-cubic-foot bag with higher specified fabric denier, consider the Asinking 20-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag; for a rigid box with rear access, the SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box provides 18 cubic feet.
Choose the D SOLUTIONS 11-Cubic-Foot Box only after checking its crossbar-width limit. Whatever the format, confirm roof load limits, fit, and installation instructions before loading.
Related Buying Guides
- Best Roof Rack Storage
- Best Van Roof Rack Storage
- Best Storage Box For Car
- Best Storage For Back Of Car
- Best Roof Racks For Cars
- Best Roof Bars For Cars
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I check whether a roof bag will fit my car and its roof setup?
Compare the bag’s listed dimensions with the usable roof area, then check whether your vehicle’s setup allows the required attachment method. Some options are described for use with or without racks, while others are rack carriers. Confirm the vehicle and product instructions, door clearance, and any restrictions before loading.
How should I protect a soft roof bag’s zipper and seams during a trip?
Close the zipper fully and position any protective flap over it as directed by the product instructions. Pack and secure the bag so its contents do not strain the closure or seams, and check them during stops. The Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Bag lists a waterproof zipper flap and reinforced welded seams.
What roof load limit should I follow when carrying luggage above the car?
Follow the vehicle manufacturer’s roof load limit and the instructions for the roof rack or carrier, using the most restrictive applicable limit. Include the weight of the carrier and luggage when checking the load. Do not assume a bag’s capacity indicates how much weight the roof can safely support.
Should I choose a soft roof bag or a hard-shell cargo box?
Choose based on the format and access you need. The listed options include soft bags and hard-shell boxes; the SportRack Vista XL is identified as a rear-opening box, while the Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Bag includes an anti-slip mat and door hooks. Check fit, attachment requirements, and instructions for either type.
What should I check before choosing a roof-rack cargo carrier?
Confirm that your vehicle has a compatible roof setup and that the carrier’s dimensions and mounting requirements suit it. The Mockins extendable carrier is listed as 64 by 39 by 5 inches, while the D SOLUTIONS box has a crossbar-width limit noted in the article verdict. Check the relevant instructions before installation.
Final Words
For a balanced soft-bag setup, the Asinking 21-Cubic-Foot Roof Bag is the practical pick, with reinforced seams, a covered zipper, an anti-slip mat, and door hooks. Choose the Mockins 35-Cubic-Foot Bag if its greater listed capacity suits your needs, after checking its dimensions against your vehicle. For a rigid option, consider the rear-opening SportRack Vista XL.
Before buying or loading any carrier, verify fit, attachment instructions, and roof load limits.


