A strong Model S tire choice should match your car’s approved size and load requirements while fitting your climate and priorities, whether that means EV-specific construction, year-round traction, or summer handling. This lineup includes the Sailun ERange EV, tires explicitly designed for electric or hybrid cars, alongside performance summer options from Michelin, Goodyear, Pirelli, and Lexani and all-season alternatives from Hankook and Atlas. The listed sizes span 18 to 22 inches, but that range does not mean every tire fits every Model S: configurations vary by vehicle and wheel setup.
Treat this ranking as a shortlist, not a fitment guarantee. Before ordering, confirm the tire size, load and speed ratings, and any vehicle-specific requirements using your door-jamb placard or owner documentation.
The Sailun ERange EV Touring is the leading choice here for shoppers prioritizing an EV-focused tire: its listing explicitly targets electric and hybrid passenger cars, gives a 235/40R19 XL size, and states a 45,000-mile limited tread-life warranty. That does not establish fitment for every Model S, so match the size and load requirements to your exact vehicle before ordering. If you need a different wheel diameter or a summer-performance tire, compare the alternatives by their listed specifications and intended use.
Our Top Picks
Best OverallExplicitly designed for electric or hybrid passenger cars, this 235/40R19 XL all-season tire lists a 45,000-mile limited tread-life warranty.
View on Amazon
20-Inch SummerGoodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5
Its 255/40R20 size and premium ultra-high-performance summer description make it a relevant performance option, with wet braking highlighted.
View on Amazon
EV PerformanceThe listing identifies use on high-performance EVs and gives a 325/35R22 size; inclined grooves are described as supporting handling and stability.
View on Amazon- Wet-Grip Focus Michelin Pilot Sport 4S
- All-Season Choice Hankook Ventus S1 AS
Compare the listed tires by size and intended use
| # | Product | Size | Rim Size | Load Capacity | Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1. Sailun ERange EVBest Overall | 235/40R19 | 19 in | 16 oz | 235/40R19 | View on Amazon |
| 2 | 2. Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 520-Inch Summer | P255/40R20 | 20 in | 16 oz | 255/40R20 | View on Amazon |
| 3 | 3. Pirelli P Zero PZ5EV Performance | 325/35R22 | 22 in | 2 lb | 325/35R22 | View on Amazon |
| 4 | 4. Michelin Pilot Sport 4SWet-Grip Focus | 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL | 18 in | 1609 lb | 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL | View on Amazon |
| 5 | 5. Hankook Ventus S1 ASAll-Season Choice | 235/45R18 | 18 in | 16 oz | 235/45R18 | View on Amazon |
| 6 | 6. Lexani LXUHP-207Warm-weather 18-inch performance drivers | 235/45ZR18 | 18 in | 1653 lb | 235/45R18 | View on Amazon |
| 7 | 7. Atlas Force UHP21-inch all-season tire pair buyers | 275/35R21 | 21 in | 1709 lb | 275/35R21 | View on Amazon |
| 8 | 8. Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 24520-inch four-tire replacement buyers | 245/45ZR20 103Y | 20 in | 1929 lb | 245/45ZR20 | View on Amazon |
| 9 | 9. Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 27520-inch two-tire replacement buyers | 275/40ZR20 | 20 in | 2094 lb | 275/40ZR20 | View on Amazon |
| 10 | 10. Horseshoe Sleipnir 218-inch all-season two-tire buyers | 235/45ZR18 98Y XL | 18 in | 1653 lb | 235/45R18(F/R) | View on Amazon |
Detailed Reviews: Best Tires For Model S

#1 · Best Overall
1. Sailun ERange EV
- Size: 235/40R19
- Rim Size: 19 in
- Load Capacity: 16 oz
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/40R19
Best for: Electric and hybrid 19-inch drivers.
Why it ranks #1: Explicitly designed for electric or hybrid passenger cars, this 235/40R19 XL all-season tire lists a 45,000-mile limited tread-life warranty.
Sailun’s ERange EV is specifically intended for electric or hybrid passenger cars, with reinforced sidewalls to compensate for battery weight and support handling and cornering. The 235/40R19 XL specification identifies its 19-inch fitment, while its all-season designation covers more than warm-weather driving.
The reinforced sidewall is intended to increase load-carrying capacity for battery weight while improving handling and cornering, a feature directly relevant to the EV and hybrid applications named in the listing. Liquid phase mixing and EcoPoint3 technology are associated with long tread life and wet- or dry-road grip. SilentTread technology and a variable pitch sequence are also listed. The 45,000-mile limited tread-life coverage and 235/40R19 size help buyers assess ownership and fitment.
- Specified for electric or hybrid passenger cars
- Reinforced sidewall supports battery-weight capacity and handling
- EcoPoint3 technology is tied to tread life and wet/dry grip
- 45,000-mile limited tread-life coverage
- The listed size is 235/40R19, so it will not match vehicles requiring another size.
Skip it if you need 235/45R18 fitment; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS H125 is listed in that size for passenger cars.
This Sailun suits EV or hybrid owners whose vehicle specifies 235/40R19 tires and who value reinforced sidewalls and stated wet/dry grip. Check the exact size before choosing; its listed fitment is 19-inch, not a universal Model S match.
Full product details
| Brand | SAILUN |
|---|---|
| Included Components | Tire Only |
| Item Dimensions | 26.42 x 9.2 x 26.42 inches |
| Item Weight | 29 pounds |
| Load Capacity | 16 ounces |
| Manufacturer | Sailun |
| Part Number | 9630813 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 45,000 Mile Limited Warranty |
| Model Number | 9630813 |
| Rim Size | 19 inches |
| Size | 235/40R19 |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 235/40R19 |
Listed on Amazon as: Sailun ERange EV Touring 235/40R19 96W XL Electric Vehicle Tire
View on Amazon
#2 · 20-Inch Summer
2. Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5
- Size: P255/40R20
- Rim Size: 20 in
- Load Capacity: 16 oz
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 255/40R20
Best for: 20-inch summer wet-braking buyers.
Why it ranks #2: Its 255/40R20 size and premium ultra-high-performance summer description make it a relevant performance option, with wet braking highlighted.
Goodyear’s Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5 is identified as a premium ultra-high-performance summer tire with superior wet braking, pairing a performance focus with luxurious comfort. Its 255/40R20 size and 20-inch rim specification make it a candidate for drivers whose vehicle calls for this exact size.
The supplied description highlights wet braking performance, a relevant benefit for drivers encountering rain during summer use, and positions the tire in the ultra-high-performance category. It also calls out luxurious comfort, balancing its braking focus with a comfort-oriented attribute. The 255/40R20 specification and 20-inch rim size define the installation match required; the listing identifies a single tire, so replacement quantity should be planned accordingly.
- Premium ultra-high-performance summer tire
- Superior wet braking is highlighted
- Luxurious comfort is stated in the description
- 255/40R20 size for a 20-inch rim is specified
- It is identified as a summer tire, limiting its stated seasonal role.
Skip it if you need year-round traction; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS H125 is listed as an all-season passenger tire.
Consider this Goodyear if your vehicle specifies 255/40R20 tires and you want a summer performance tire with wet-braking emphasis and stated comfort. Its summer classification makes it a poor match for year-round needs.
Full product details
| Brand | Goodyear |
|---|---|
| Included Components | Tire |
| Item Dimensions | 28.03 x 10.24 x 28.03 inches |
| Item Weight | 25.6 pounds |
| Load Capacity | 16 ounces |
| Manufacturer | GOODYEAR TIRE AND RUBBER CO |
| Part Number | 103001588 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | Replacement Limited Warranty |
| Model Number | 103001588 |
| Rim Size | 20 inches |
| Size | P255/40R20 |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 255/40R20 |
Listed on Amazon as: Goodyear 255/40R20 101W XL GOODYEAR EAG F1 ASYM 5 SBL T0
View on Amazon
#3 · EV Performance
3. Pirelli P Zero PZ5
- Size: 325/35R22
- Rim Size: 22 in
- Load Capacity: 2 lb
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 325/35R22
Best for: 22-inch luxury EV summer drivers.
Why it ranks #3: The listing identifies use on high-performance EVs and gives a 325/35R22 size; inclined grooves are described as supporting handling and stability.
Pirelli’s P Zero PZ5 combines a plasticized rubber compound for wet- and dry-weather braking and handling with tread features aimed at a quieter ride. Its 325/35R22 size is intended for high-performance coupes, sedans, and EVs, offering a specific option for vehicles using 22-inch wheels.
The plasticized compound is specified to boost braking and handling in wet and dry weather, while steep, inclined groove angles improve handling and stability. Progressive sipes and carefully designed tread blocks lower road noise, offering a comfort benefit alongside its performance focus. Pirelli also says the optimized tread pattern improves durability for longer tread life. The 325/35R22 size requires a matching 22-inch fitment, and the description specifies use when temperatures stay above 45 degrees Fahrenheit.
- Plasticized compound boosts wet- and dry-weather braking and handling
- Inclined groove angles improve handling and stability
- Sipes and tread blocks reduce road noise
- Optimized tread pattern is stated to improve durability
- The stated operating condition is temperatures consistently above 45°F.
Skip it if you regularly drive in colder conditions; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS H125 is listed for all-season use including light winter weather.
This Pirelli suits a high-performance coupe, sedan, or EV specified for 325/35R22 tires and warm conditions. Its 45°F temperature guidance is a meaningful seasonal boundary, so it is not the listed choice for colder-weather use.
Full product details
| Brand | Pirelli |
|---|---|
| Included Components | Tire Only |
| Item Dimensions | 30.98 x 13.03 x 30.98 inches |
| Item Weight | 39.7 pounds |
| Load Capacity | 2 pounds |
| Manufacturer | Pirelli |
| Part Number | 4410900 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | Standard Manufacturer Warranty |
| Model Number | 4410900 |
| Rim Size | 22 inches |
| Size | 325/35R22 |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 325/35R22 |
Listed on Amazon as: Pirelli P Zero (PZ5) Performance 325/35R22 110Y Passenger Tire
View on Amazon
#4 · Wet-Grip Focus
4. Michelin Pilot Sport 4S
- Size: 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL
- Rim Size: 18 in
- Load Capacity: 1609 lb
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL
Best for: Summer-grip 18-inch performance drivers.
Why it ranks #4: This 245/40ZR18 XL summer tire lists high-speed control, dry grip, and wet braking, but its seasonal use limits year-round suitability.
Michelin’s Pilot Sport 4S emphasizes exceptional dry grip and wet braking, giving drivers a summer tire focused on control in changing road conditions. The 245/40ZR18 XL specification identifies its wheel and tire size, while its high-speed handling focus suits buyers seeking performance rather than an all-season option.
Michelin describes the Pilot Sport 4S as a max-performance summer tire derived from the Pilot Super Sport, with excellent road handling and control even at high speed. Exceptional dry grip and wet braking make its stated strengths relevant across both dry and wet summer driving. Its 245/40ZR18 XL size calls for a matching 18-inch wheel and vehicle specification. The listing is for one tire only, so buyers planning a full replacement need to account for the required quantity.
- Exceptional dry grip is a stated performance strength
- Wet braking performance is specifically highlighted
- Road handling and control are emphasized at high speed
- 245/40ZR18 XL specification is clearly provided
- The listing is for one tire only, not a complete set.
Skip it if you need year-round or light-winter use; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS H125 is specified as an all-season tire.
This Michelin suits drivers prioritizing dry grip, wet braking, and high-speed control in summer conditions. Check the 245/40ZR18 XL specification against the vehicle, and note that this listing supplies one tire rather than a set.
Full product details
| Brand | MICHELIN |
|---|---|
| Included Components | 3-year flat tire changing assistance, 6 years standard defect warranty, 60 Day Satisfaction Guarantee, MICHELIN Promise Plan, Rims not included |
| Item Dimensions | 25.7 x 9.65 x 25.7 inches |
| Item Weight | 10.4 kg |
| Load Capacity | 1609 pounds |
| Manufacturer | MICHELIN |
| Part Number | 37666 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 30,000 Mile Manufacturer's Treadwear Limited Warranty, 6 Year limited warranty |
| Model Number | 37666 |
| Rim Size | 18 inches |
| Size | 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL |
Listed on Amazon as: Michelin Pilot Sport 4S 245/40ZR18 (97Y) XL (Set of 1 Tire Only)
View on Amazon
#5 · All-Season Choice
5. Hankook Ventus S1 AS
- Size: 235/45R18
- Rim Size: 18 in
- Load Capacity: 16 oz
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/45R18
Best for: All-season 18-inch passenger cars.
Why it ranks #5: The 235/45R18 XL all-season tire is described for wet, dry, and light winter conditions, with four grooves to channel water.
The Hankook Ventus S1 AS H125 uses an all-season rubber compound for year-round traction, including wet, dry, and light winter conditions. Four wide grooves channel water from the tread, while its 235/45R18 XL specification targets passenger cars requiring an 18-inch tire.
The all-season compound supports traction in wet, dry, and light winter conditions, giving drivers a broader stated seasonal range than a summer-only tire. Four wide grooves funnel water away to boost wet traction, and reinforced construction increases strength and durability for higher load carrying capacity and longer tread life. Hankook also says its optimized design lowers road noise and vibration. The 235/45R18 size requires the corresponding wheel and vehicle specification for installation.
- All-season compound covers wet, dry, and light winter conditions
- Four wide grooves boost wet traction
- Reinforced construction increases strength and durability
- Optimized design lowers road noise and vibration
- The stated winter capability is limited to light winter weather.
Skip it if you need a tire specifically described for colder winter conditions; the listed Hankook features specify light winter weather only.
Choose the Hankook for a passenger car specified for 235/45R18 tires when year-round traction, wet-road grooves, and reduced cabin noise matter. Its stated winter scope is light winter weather, not a dedicated severe-winter claim.
Full product details
| Brand | HANKOOK |
|---|---|
| Included Components | Tire Only |
| Item Dimensions | 26.3 x 9.3 x 26.3 inches |
| Item Weight | 24.5 pounds |
| Load Capacity | 16 ounces |
| Manufacturer | Hankook |
| Part Number | 1030060 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | Standard Manufacturer Warranty |
| Model Number | 1030060 |
| Rim Size | 18 inches |
| Size | 235/45R18 |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 235/45R18 |
Listed on Amazon as: Hankook Ventus S1 AS (H125) UHP 235/45R18 98V XL Passenger Tire
View on Amazon
#6
6. Lexani LXUHP-207
- Size: 235/45ZR18
- Rim Size: 18 in
- Load Capacity: 1653 lb
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/45R18
Best for: Warm-weather 18-inch performance drivers.
Why it ranks #6: Its 235/45ZR18 XL size and 50,000-mile limited tread-life warranty are notable, though it is intended for warmer-weather performance use.
The Lexani LXUHP-207 pairs a V-shaped tread pattern with wide lateral grooves, supporting high-speed traction and braking while moving water out of the tread. Its 235/45ZR18 size and 50,000-mile limited tread-life coverage make it a warm-weather performance option for drivers prioritizing handling and a quieter ride.
The V-shaped tread is specified to improve traction and braking at higher speeds, giving performance-oriented drivers a concrete reason to consider this tire for warm-weather road use. Wide lateral grooves evacuate water to enhance hydroplaning resistance, while the computer-optimized design lowers road noise and vibration for a more comfortable cabin. The 235/45ZR18 size requires a matching 18-inch wheel and vehicle specification; the listed 50,000-mile limited tread-life coverage adds a defined ownership consideration.
- V-shaped pattern supports traction and braking at higher speeds
- Wide lateral grooves enhance hydroplaning resistance
- Computer-optimized design lowers road noise and vibration
- 50,000-mile limited manufacturer tread-life coverage
- Its stated use is for warmer weather, not year-round conditions.
Skip it if you need one tire for light winter conditions; the Hankook Ventus S1 AS H125 is listed as all-season.
Choose this Lexani for a vehicle specified for 235/45ZR18 tires and warm-weather performance, especially if lower road noise matters. Its stated warmer-weather use is an important boundary for drivers who need year-round traction.
Full product details
| Brand | Lexani |
|---|---|
| Included Components | Tires |
| Item Dimensions | 26 x 9.5 x 26 inches |
| Item Weight | 30 pounds |
| Load Capacity | 1653 pounds |
| Manufacturer | Lexani |
| Part Number | LXST2071845040 |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | Full Manufacturer Warranty |
| Model Number | LXST2071845040 |
| Rim Size | 18 inches |
| Size | 235/45ZR18 |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 235/45R18 |
Listed on Amazon as: Lexani LXUHP-207 235/45ZR18 98W XL
View on Amazon
#7
7. Atlas Force UHP
- Size: 275/35R21
- Rim Size: 21 in
- Load Capacity: 1709 lb
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 275/35R21
Best for: 21-inch all-season tire pair buyers.
Why it ranks #7: This 275/35R21 all-season passenger tire has a listed 50,000-mile treadwear warranty, but the listing does not identify it as EV-specific.
The Atlas Tire Force UHP listing supplies two all-season tires in 275/35R21, pairing a broad seasonal designation with a specific 21-inch fitment. Its description identifies performance and high-performance use for passenger vehicles, crossovers, and SUVs, giving buyers a defined application range to consider.
The all-season classification makes this listing relevant to buyers seeking a tire described for multiple seasons, while the product description names passenger vehicles, crossovers, and SUVs as intended applications. Its 275/35R21 size and 21-inch rim specification narrow fitment to vehicles requiring that combination. The two-tire quantity supports a paired replacement plan, but buyers replacing all four should account for the set size. A 50,000-mile treadwear warranty is stated in the description.
- All-season designation is stated
- Description names passenger vehicles, crossovers, and SUVs
- 275/35R21 size matches a 21-inch rim specification
- Description states a 50,000-mile treadwear warranty
- The listing contains two tires rather than a complete four-tire set.
Skip it if you need 235/40R19 EV-specific sizing; the Sailun ERange EV is specified for electric or hybrid passenger cars.
This Atlas pair suits buyers whose passenger vehicle, crossover, or SUV calls for 275/35R21 all-season tires. Its two-tire quantity is the key boundary for full replacements, and the listed size must match the vehicle specification.
Full product details
| Brand | Atlas Tires |
|---|---|
| Included Components | Tire Only |
| Item Dimensions | 27 x 27 x 9 inches |
| Item Weight | 68 pounds |
| Load Capacity | 1709 pounds |
| Manufacturer | Atlas Tire |
| Part Number | 221017747 |
| Model Number | 221017747 |
| Rim Size | 21 inches |
| Size | 275/35R21 |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 275/35R21 |
Listed on Amazon as: 2 x Atlas Tire Force UHP 275/35R21 99W SL All Season Passenger Tires
View on Amazon
#8
8. Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 245
- Size: 245/45ZR20 103Y
- Rim Size: 20 in
- Load Capacity: 1929 lb
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 245/45ZR20
Best for: 20-inch four-tire replacement buyers.
Why it ranks #8: The set lists four 245/45ZR20 XL high-performance tires, but supplies little additional detail about intended conditions or tread performance.
This Mastertrack M-TRAC HP listing provides a set of four high-performance XL tires, distinguishing it from pair-only listings. The 245/45ZR20 103Y specification identifies the tire size and rating, while the 20-inch rim detail helps buyers assess whether the set matches their vehicle’s required fitment.
A four-tire set can simplify sourcing when replacing all tires, provided the vehicle calls for the listed 245/45ZR20 size. The title identifies the tires as high performance and XL, and the specification adds a 103Y rating and 20-inch rim size for fitment comparison. The supplied product information does not describe tread design, seasonal use, wet grip, or noise behavior, so those considerations cannot be assessed from these listed facts.
- Listing supplies a set of four tires
- High-performance designation is stated
- 245/45ZR20 103Y size and rating are specified
- 20-inch rim size is listed
- Its 245/45ZR20 size is a specific fitment, not a universal replacement size.
Skip it if you need 275/40ZR20 sizing; the Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 275/40ZR20 listing supplies two tires in that size.
This set suits buyers seeking four high-performance XL tires in the exact 245/45ZR20 specification. Compare that size and 103Y rating with the vehicle requirements; the listing provides no stated seasonal or tread-behavior details.
Full product details
| Brand | Mastertrack |
|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 1929 pounds |
| Part Number | MASTHP011-A4B |
| Model Number | MASTHP011-A4B |
| Rim Size | 20 inches |
| Size | 245/45ZR20 103Y |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 245/45ZR20 |
Listed on Amazon as: Set of 4 Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 245/45ZR20 103Y XL High Performance Tires
View on Amazon
#9
9. Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 275
- Size: 275/40ZR20
- Rim Size: 20 in
- Load Capacity: 2094 lb
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 275/40ZR20
Best for: 20-inch two-tire replacement buyers.
Why it ranks #9: This set of two 275/40ZR20 XL high-performance tires provides a listed size and load capacity, with no further use or warranty details.
This Mastertrack M-TRAC HP listing supplies two high-performance XL tires in size 275/40ZR20, making the quantity and wheel specification its clearest differentiators. The 106W designation and listed 2,094-pound load capacity provide additional identifying specifications for buyers comparing replacements against their vehicle requirements.
The set-of-two format can support a paired replacement when the vehicle calls for 275/40ZR20 tires, rather than requiring buyers to source each tire separately. Its 20-inch rim specification clarifies the wheel size, and XL construction is stated in the title alongside the 106W rating. The listing also gives a load capacity of 2,094 pounds. These details help narrow a fitment comparison, but the provided information does not describe tread behavior or seasonal capability.
- Listing includes two tires
- High-performance designation appears in the title
- 275/40ZR20 size is specified
- XL and 106W specifications are listed
- The two-tire listing is not a complete four-tire set.
Skip it if you need four tires together; the Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 245/45ZR20 listing supplies a set of four.
This listing fits buyers sourcing a pair of high-performance 275/40ZR20 XL tires. Use the stated size, 106W rating, and load capacity in your vehicle comparison; buyers replacing all four should account for the two-tire quantity.
Full product details
| Brand | Mastertrack |
|---|---|
| Load Capacity | 2094 pounds |
| Part Number | MASTHP010-A2S |
| Model Number | MASTHP010-A2S |
| Rim Size | 20 inches |
| Size | 275/40ZR20 |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 275/40ZR20 |
Listed on Amazon as: Set of 2 Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 275/40ZR20 106W XL High Performance Tires
View on Amazon
#10
10. Horseshoe Sleipnir 2
- Size: 235/45ZR18 98Y XL
- Rim Size: 18 in
- Load Capacity: 1653 lb
- Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description: 235/45R18(F/R)
Best for: 18-inch all-season two-tire buyers.
Why it ranks #10: The 235/45ZR18 XL listing describes an all-season UHP tire, but provides no clear EV-specific features or detailed performance information.
The HORSESHOE SLEIPNIR 2 listing combines an all-season designation with a two-tire quantity in 235/45ZR18 98Y XL, giving buyers several concrete fitment and purchasing details. Its 4-ply and M/S markings are also stated in the title for shoppers comparing tire specifications.
The title identifies this as an ultra-high-performance all-season radial, so its stated seasonal category can suit buyers seeking an all-season option rather than a summer-only listing. The two-tire quantity may fit a paired replacement plan, while the 235/45ZR18 size and 18-inch rim specification clarify the wheel match to check. The 98Y XL and 4-ply markings provide further comparison details; the supplied information does not describe specific wet, dry, or winter performance features.
- All-season classification appears in the title
- Listing includes two tires
- 235/45ZR18 size and 18-inch rim are specified
- 98Y XL and 4-ply markings are provided
- The two-tire quantity does not cover a four-tire replacement.
Skip it if you need a complete four-tire set; the Mastertrack M-TRAC HP 245/45ZR20 listing is supplied as four tires.
This HORSESHOE listing suits buyers sourcing two 235/45ZR18 all-season tires and comparing the listed 98Y XL and 4-ply details. Confirm the vehicle’s required size, and account for the pair quantity if replacing all four.
Full product details
| Brand | HORSESHOE |
|---|---|
| Included Components | Tires Only |
| Load Capacity | 1653 pounds |
| Manufacturer | HORSESHOE TIRE GROUP |
| Part Number | SLEIPNIR ANDALUSIA UHP |
| Manufacturer Warranty Description | 2 Year Manufacturer Warranty |
| Model Number | SLEIPNIR ANDALUSIA UHP |
| Rim Size | 18 inches |
| Size | 235/45ZR18 98Y XL |
| Vehicle Tire ISO Metric Size Description | 235/45R18(F/R) |
Listed on Amazon as: HORSESHOE SLEIPNIR 2 New 235/45ZR18 235/45R18 98Y XL Andalusia Ultra High Performance Radial Tires 235 45 18 Load Range XL 4-Ply BSW M/S UHP All Season (2, 235/45ZR18 98Y XL)
View on AmazonThe fitment trap: matching diameter is not enough
A listed wheel diameter alone cannot confirm that a tire fits your Model S. This selection spans 18-, 19-, 20-, 21-, and 22-inch rims, and the tire sizes also differ in width and aspect ratio: for example, 235/40R19 on the Sailun ERange EV is not interchangeable by assumption with 245/45ZR20 on the Mastertrack set. Model S fitments can depend on the particular vehicle and wheel configuration, and the product data here does not provide a complete compatibility chart.
Check the tire-size placard and owner documentation, then verify the full size, load index, speed rating, and any required fitment markings before purchase. Do not choose solely because the rim diameter appears to match.
If replacing fewer than four tires, confirm with a qualified tire professional that the proposed combination is suitable for your vehicle and drivetrain.
Seasonal intent can change the right answer
A tire described for summer use is not a substitute for an all-season option when you need broader seasonal coverage. The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S, Lexani LXUHP-207, Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5, and Pirelli P Zero PZ5 are listed as summer or warmer-weather performance products; the Pirelli description says it is intended for temperatures consistently above 45 degrees Fahrenheit. By contrast, the Sailun ERange EV and Hankook Ventus S1 AS are identified as all-season tires, and Hankook’s description mentions light winter conditions.
These labels still do not establish winter-tire capability or suitability for severe snow. A possible mismatch is buying a summer-focused tire for cold or winter conditions based only on its size.
Decide first which temperatures and road conditions you regularly face, then narrow the choices to the appropriate stated tire type.
How to Choose Model S Tires
Confirm size and vehicle requirements
Start with the complete tire size and required ratings shown for your exact Model S, not just the wheel diameter. The products here range from 235/45R18 and 235/40R19 to 275/35R21 and 325/35R22, so the options are not interchangeable. Listed sizes include XL examples such as the Sailun 235/40R19 96W XL and Michelin 245/40ZR18 97Y XL, while the Pirelli is 325/35R22 110Y.
Use your vehicle placard or documentation to verify size, load and speed requirements before ordering. Buyers keeping their existing wheels should prioritize an exact specification match; those changing wheels need to verify the entire wheel-and-tire setup with a qualified professional.
Choose seasonal coverage
Look for a tire whose stated seasonal type matches your local conditions and driving calendar. The Pirelli P Zero PZ5 description calls for temperatures consistently above 45 degrees Fahrenheit, and the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S and Lexani LXUHP-207 are also summer or warmer-weather performance choices. The Sailun ERange EV and Hankook Ventus S1 AS are listed as all-season; Hankook specifically mentions wet, dry, and light winter conditions.
That wording does not promise performance in severe winter weather. Drivers who use their Model S through changing seasons may prefer the all-season options, while those in consistently warm conditions who prioritize summer performance can consider the summer tires, subject to exact fitment.
Balance EV focus and performance priorities
Check whether EV-specific construction or a particular performance emphasis matters most to you. Sailun explicitly designs the ERange EV for electric or hybrid cars, cites reinforced sidewalls for battery weight, and lists SilentTread technology; its size is 235/40R19 XL. The Pirelli listing also includes EVs in its intended vehicle types, but its listed size is 325/35R22.
For performance handling, the Michelin highlights dry grip and wet braking, while the Goodyear is described as an ultra-high-performance summer tire with wet braking. An EV-focused buyer can start with Sailun’s stated design purpose, while a shopper seeking a summer-performance tire can compare Michelin, Goodyear, and Pirelli; none should be selected without checking fitment.
Which tires should I choose for my Model S?
Start with the tire size and ratings specified for your exact Model S, then choose by climate and intended use. If an EV-focused all-season option in the listed 235/40R19 size matches your vehicle, Sailun ERange EV is the strongest starting point because it is explicitly designed for electric or hybrid cars. For warm-weather performance, compare Michelin Pilot Sport 4S, Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5, and Pirelli P Zero PZ5 only if their listed sizes fit your setup.
Hankook Ventus S1 AS is a relevant all-season alternative in 235/45R18, while Lexani LXUHP-207 is another warmer-weather 18-inch option. These sizes are not interchangeable, and this product data does not confirm Model S fitment.
Verify the vehicle placard, load and speed ratings, and any applicable wheel requirements before buying.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I confirm the correct tire size and load rating for my specific Model S?
Use the tire information on your vehicle’s placard or owner documentation, then confirm the full size and required load and speed ratings before ordering. The listings show different sizes and ratings, and the Sailun listing’s 235/40R19 XL specification does not by itself establish fitment for every Model S.
Are summer tires suitable for the temperatures and weather where I drive?
Choose a summer tire only if its intended use suits the temperatures and conditions you regularly encounter. The Michelin Pilot Sport 4S, Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 5, and Pirelli P Zero PZ5 are listed as performance options, but the supplied product details do not establish their suitability for your local climate. Check the listing and consult a tire professional.
Should I replace all four tires at once or can I replace only a pair?
Whether you can replace only a pair depends on your vehicle’s requirements and the condition and specifications of the remaining tires. Check your owner documentation and ask a qualified tire professional before mixing tires. These listings include single tires, pairs, and a set of four, but that packaging alone does not determine what your Model S requires.
How should I compare listings with different wheel diameters?
Treat each listed size as specific to its tire and wheel setup; different diameters are not interchangeable. Start with the size on your Model S placard and confirm that the full size, load rating, speed rating, and wheel requirements match. The listings span several diameters, so do not choose based on a partial size match.
Does an EV-focused tire listing guarantee fitment for my Model S?
No. The Sailun ERange EV Touring listing explicitly targets electric and hybrid passenger cars and gives a 235/40R19 XL size, but that does not confirm fitment for every Model S. Verify your vehicle’s required size and ratings first; use the tire’s stated intended use as a comparison point, not a substitute for fitment checks.
Final Words
Start by matching the tire size, load and speed ratings, and wheel requirements on your exact Model S. If the listed 235/40R19 XL size fits, Sailun ERange EV Touring is the leading EV-focused option in this roundup. For a different setup or warm-weather performance, compare the alternatives only when their listed sizes and intended use match your needs.
Confirm fitment before ordering; listed sizes are not interchangeable.


